Comment by extension | Hacker News Reader

Comment by extension | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

That's an example of value derived from consuming generic data, but how do you get value from providing it?

Providing generic third party access is a rare case in business. Usually, data is used by third parties for a specific purpose that requires substantial domain knowledge, in which case an RDF description is probably redundant and useless.

There may be business models based on generic data but those businesses will face a serious bootstrapping problem as they will likely require either a critical mass of generic data providers or consumers, which are mutually dependent.

The bootstrapping will have to be grassroots, as it was for the original "unstructured" web, which succeeded due to the ease of publishing HTML documents, which is much simpler than publishing structured data.

"how do you get value from providing it" - how do you get value from publishing anything on the web? The same principles apply. The value comes from making information more readily available, so people can find out new things, make connections, do their jobs better. If you want to make money from it (and of course a lot of data has already been paid for by the taxpayer) then you can do all the usual stuff: charge for access, charge for services built on top of the data, provide it free and use it to build your brand or to gain attention of people that can be sold to advertisers etc.

One important use case is publishing data for re-use within an enterprise or other organisation - it doesn't necessarily need to always be public.

I concur. We have largely solved the publishing issue with linked data. Now we aim to realise the read-write Web of Data - http://vimeo.com/3663028 is a screen cast explaining and demoing how this can be done (and this is a grass-rooted, open community project building upon deployed and already used technologies whilst offering a generic processing model - consider signing up and contribute!)

Cheers, Michael

Reply on news.ycombinator.com