Judging by the screenshots ...
Why bother judging by the screenshots? There are plenty of actual Windows 8 devices out there. It's fairly pointless to post guesswork about the UI.
Why bother judging by the screenshots? There are plenty of actual Windows 8 devices out there. It's fairly pointless to post guesswork about the UI.
You can't experience using a product with some photographs.
Similarly, you can't pretend to be a judge of good design based on a couple of photographs.
This guy was clearly just spouting an opinion based on nothing, and we shouldn't respond to such comments as if they deserve merit.
More likely, looking at screenshots would divert her attention to secondary things like the textures and illustrations used in the apps rather than the actual UI design.