Projects: especially difficult/interesting/field-relevant ones.
Honesty: if I can't immediately tell that you are over-stating your experience, I will find out in the phone screen.
Fit: something that helps me think that you'll be a good fit with my team from a personality stand-point. This may be represented by listing hobbies (though be careful with this) and the types of projects you work on.
Attention to detail: Your resume should look like something that's professionally crafted. If it doesn't, I am going to assume your code looks the same way.
Back when I was applying for jobs several years ago, I would tailor my resume for the job that I was applying for. The more your experiences matches the listing, the better. In my case, being somewhat of a generalist, I have some experience developing web, desktop, cli/server and embedded code, so I would rewrite my highlights at each job where appropriate to best address the skills being looked for.