Since a few weeks this feature was completely broken for me. 90% of the time, hitting "reply" lead to an email with just a sentence or a word even without clicking/selecting anything and I had no idea what happened. I was always forced to delete the current mail and start again of go back and forth between "reply" and "forward" for the whole conversation to appear!
Maybe I was not the only one with this problem so they decided to disable it by default?