Hacker News Reader

Comment by btilly | Hacker News Reader

Actually it is $8000 for 50% difference because it isn't just the initial $5000, you also would have to pay $3000 for marketing.

And if the OP knows more about how to market than you do, you'd actually need to spend more than that to market your idea as well as the OP will.

View on HN

Good points, you're absolutely right.

http://www.resourcenation.com/blog/the-6-ps-of-marketing/396...

I hold dual degrees in computer science and business management. I think I can do my own marketing, thank you. If not I know people who will for a small fee.

I don't understand what your tone is responding to.

I think he's implying that marketing isn't much of a skill - that competent people with a good product should market themselves. I've heard this from engineers before though can't say I know enough about the intricacies of marketing to weigh in.

I know some great marketing people. I have never met an engineer that gets even close. But I am sure there are exceptions.

Who knows the market of your product better? The person who works hard on it for two months and knows it inside and out, or some guy you met anonymously over the Internet who wants $8000 in exchange for half your stock, just to market it?

Think about it, what does he know about the product? Nothing. You'll spend a lot of time explaining it to him in full details and then he markets those details to strangers, parroting your words.

Knowing your product too well is not necessarily an asset when it comes to marketing, especially if you created it yourself. There is often a tendency to overvalue features which were difficult to code rather than features which add real value. Knowing your consumers is far more important.

You don't need "a lot of time explaining it to him in full details" - he doesn't need to know all the details. If you can't explain the product to him in under a minute, you need spend more time thinking about what is important and what not.

I said "if" for a reason, because this is addressed to a broad audience with different skill sets.

For the record the reason why I made that point is that I would personally value that $3k at higher than $3k because I do not have marketing experience. And yes, there are lots of people who will take a fee to market for me - but I'm not in a particularly good position to know whether I'm getting a good one.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com