Hacker News Reader

Comment by wronglebowski | Hacker News Reader

I'm all for more open models, but talk is cheap and this is a rather pointless announcement without anything backing it up. Publish your weights and HF repo or shut up IMO.

View on HN

Is that all that a company about to give away the product of 10,000 GPUs running for a month gets to be now? give it away without a single promotional post or shut up? I support open source as much as the person but this is pretty caustic.

I am also starting to take issue with "we've developed a new cutting edge model, and nobody can use it" announcements. Most recently with Google's Argon, at least they were using it internally and they'd be slowly rolling it out. This one is from a company I've never heard of, they're not releasing weights or offering API access at this point, it feels like a fairly worthless announcement.

It says in the very beginning that everything will be opened up by the end of the month. Maybe slightly annoying to you but not worthless. I for one am very excited to see some new American open models since we have called so far behind the Chinese. Looking forward to trying it out.

There have been previous "we will release the model" when the model release never comes in the past.

I think the comment you are replying to is unnecessarily hostile too though.

Show me the mone^H^H^HWEIGHTS

The open weight community really is an odd one. Millions of Dollars for pre and post training given away for free and most often with very permissive licenses that allow commercial use (be it US, EU or mostly Chinese)

Yet going by the comments on localLlaMA or HN, those companies are the devil :-D. Colour me surprised.

You know, the other night I trained a model on my secret stash of GPUs, that now outperforms Opus 5.5 on pelican benchmark and Jev on classification speed, while running on a potato.

Will release weights soon.

You don't get claim to be open and then not release your actual product.

In the case of Facebook, no good thing they do will ever undo the evil things they've done, let alone the evil things they're still doing right now. How convenient for the devil that a single act of "charity" should make him immune from all criticism. By all means, praise whatever good Facebook does in the world, but don't kid yourself about what Facebook is.

I don’t understand what is wrong with some people lol. It says in the very beginning everything will be opened up by the end of the month. It’s like a bunch of toddlers throwing their milk cup on the ground and pouting because they can’t have their new toy right now!

Yes -- because they're late to the party (high performing open weights models have been a thing for a couple of years now), and therefore will be compared with all the other open-weights model providers they are competing against.

It's not just that they are doing users a favor with weights; they are just as much seeking favors with attention and usage (in a crowded market!).

> give it away without a single promotional post or shut up?

I think the point is that people are happy to see promotional posts when they actually release it, but only then and not before.

Unfortunately pinky promises from corporations to release something at some indeterminate time in the future aren't worth the bytes they're stored in, especially in the AI industry which is full of grifters and charlatans.

They claim that they will release the model as open weights later this month.

That means that they have the 31th of October as the deadline to make true their claims.

The fact that they give early access to some may mean that they want some beta testers before the public release.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com