Hacker News Reader

Comment by slopinthebag | Hacker News Reader

i don't use svelte/kit for technical reasons, but there is no doubt they have the best developer experience of all the js frameworks, it's well-considered and coherent. they have the most aura for sure.

View on HN

Needing bespoke svelte-specific tooling for _everything_ is pretty annoying when it comes to developer experience IMO. It is just overly custom when you could use something like solid and have similar performance but easy tooling integration due to just being typescript and tsx syntax. Like you can’t use typescript 7 right now in svelte, oxlint / oxfmt doesn’t fully support svelte either among other things like storybook’s mcp server not supporting svelte.

solid requires it's own jsx transform, and it's framework (imo) is not as ergonomic. but yes both are great.

i do think react (without a framework) is the beat option though.

There's other rough edges too (generics for example), but the absolute chasm between svelte and JSX tooling quality and it was a major reason for me dropping it.

You can fire up a solid project and get close to react's speed and quality even with earlier preview versions. Comparison aside, the reliability and speed of svelte tooling has felt extremely lacking on larger projects to the point i resent working on my 3 year old sveltekit codebase.

lol Great insight. I really trust an opinion about something you admittedly don't use. Also is "aura" a technical term?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com