Hacker News Reader

> so superior that it went rogue and successfully attacked all the things should be critiqued and not believed until otherwise proven.

Your statement is very vague, but if you refer to the HuggingFace incident, a third party (METR) has been called to analyze it, and their report is public.

View on HN

Correct. That is one of a few of them and thank you for the name of the third party. I read it, and mostly have the same opinion.

If I make a computer virus and then it works, did it go rogue or did it do what I told it to? The claim is that the agent/software/whatever decided on its own to do nefarious acts, and that is what I doubt. I think the guilty code did what it was written to do, albeit some distance from the humans' direct orders.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com