Hacker News Reader

So, Excel is just the poor man's shadow IT? I like that picture.

By the time it takes to make a custom filtered table non extensible UI for an api, the excel guy is finished three times over

I can’t count the number of demos I’ve seen that were “small team, multiple sprints” to produce something that could have been done in a lazy afternoon in excel by a single person.

It’s a common pattern in enterprise IT to take a useful spreadsheet and turn it into an application. Without fail, they turn into a forever chase of excel features re-implemented (and poorly) on some front end. Entire teams dedicated to features that would be two clicks away in excel ootb.

Indeed. Sometimes it's hard not to think about gaslighting in this field.

Yes, I have already three such projects on my CV, failed attempts to replace Excel.

The root cause for failure is always the same, not understanding all use cases for 100% of the department users instead of only the representative group present during UI/UX sessions, coupled with the human natural resistance to change.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com