B. You want to debate theodicy? Might as well debate nature vs nurture or male vs female or emacs vs vim.
> evil and chaos couldn't exist without a god
God created humans for reasons I wouldn't understand, but we have free will which means we can choose what we do.
Without Hitler's father he couldn't have existed. So is Hitler's father responsible for the evil of Hitler? It's not a rhetorical question btw, I have no clue, and you don't either. The issue is you think that you do, which is the typical ridiculousness of the educated dotards who think they can out reason life itself.
Anyway, I rather not argue, because nothing of my point can be proven by logic as neither can it be disproved. I would simply say you need to seek out mystery and spiritual experience, and you will find that there is much more to life than what you have thought.