Comment by trollbridge | Hacker News Reader

Comment by trollbridge | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

My state has tried this (very low sentences, often just a few days in jail, if that) and it doesn’t help the repeat offender rate at all.

Likewise, virtually everyone poor has access to mental health services, healthcare in general, addiction help and so on. That doesn’t do any good for people who refuse to use it. Sometimes a court orders someone to attend their mental health provider appointments, drug rehab, etc as terms of a sentence.

Reprioritising enforcement for drugs hasn’t helped either. It just means fentanyl is everywhere. It turns out some drugs are actually bad.

As far as “make police enforce visible plates” - that simply leads to more high conflict situations where the person they pull over is going to run; do you want more police chases ending in a violent arrest?

> My state has tried this (very low sentences, often just a few days in jail, if that) and it doesn’t help the repeat offender rate

Doesn't do anything unless you also get consistent about catching people

>Likewise, virtually everyone poor has access to mental health services, healthcare in general, addiction help and so on.

Really? If so, that's amazing. What state in the US has actually given all people access to mental health services and addiction help.

> Reprioritising enforcement for drugs hasn’t helped either. It just means fentanyl is everywhere.

Fentanyl is a thing because strict enforcement necessitates drugs that are more compact/easier to hide. Many other countries still have heroine.

>As far as “make police enforce visible plates” - that simply leads to more high conflict situations where the person they pull over is going to run; do you want more police chases ending in a violent arrest?

I would suggest focusing on impounding vehicles rather than chasing people.

Lots of states in the U.S. have a comprehensive Medicaid system where someone not otherwise covered by insurance can access healthcare. In some states it is better than others. My own state happens to be exceptional.

That doesn't mean you can force everyone who needs mental health services to go actually avail themselves of them.

You can't impound a vehicle without stopping the person driving it first. Most people don't use non visible plates anyway; they would first steal tags from another vehicle.

"My state"?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com