100% disagree! Do not mix and cherry pick terms and definitions to make your point. That's not scientific -) Take e.g. a look in https://opensciencemooc.eu/ and check a nice accepted handbook like "The Turing Way" [1]
The Turing Way seems great and I'm all for education. One of the most interesting conversation topics in this thread is, to me, how to create the necessary incentive structures. Know how is only part of the way. We need to secure the credit assignment for "openness" both in academia and industry.