Did you consider just making it a list of links? If you want to hide the link targets you can do that with JS. Dropdown list is kind of unnecessary, I think.
Yeah you're right, that would be a lot better. To be honest we kinda just threw it together in a couple hrs and forgot about it.
If I recall, I think the over-styled but less-usable drop-down list was a deliberate decision, much like the call to setTimeout.
(I'm a housemate of StuieK and Firehed, and also contributed to the page)
Tumblr is in NY!
Ah you're right! Forgot about that, did I miss any others?