Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by jollyllama | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

jollyllama

It's not clear that non-mercenary Arab armies are much better in this respect.

View on HN

It's not clear that Western armies are better either, as we've seen time and again in Iran, Afghanistan and Syria.

Politically constrained. It's just the stated goal is impossible given the political RoE.

> It's just the stated goal is impossible given the political RoE.

People need to keep in mind tactical versus strategic success. For Iran, the military operation was a complete tactical success, it's just that the strategic goals — assuming there were any to begin with, which seems to be an unanswered question — were not, and it was questionable whether military operations were a useful tool to achieve them at all.

“War is the continuation of policy with other means.” — Carl von Clausewitz

'What is one's stated policy / goal, and is war a useful tool for achieve it', is a question that needs to be asked by civilian leadership. Sometimes (often?) the answer is "no".

I'm not aware of any mass desertions by Western armies.

There was in Vietnam which is why the US army ditched the draft.

What are you talking about here, exactly?

It looks like the strait is still closed, the Taliban is back in charge and Syria is run by a former ISIS fighter. I think maybe the point is that the US has put in a lot of effort and resources into these areas with no outcomes benefitting our country, or the the world even

None of that involved western soldiers running away from fight or being misled to leave the fight. So, again, what are you talking about here?

Armies of Sand: The Past, Present, and Future of Arab Military Effectiveness by Kenneth M. Pollack

It's not a perfect book, but it illustrates a lot of military failures that haven't really been encountered much in the West in the last 80 years.

Most southern Yemenis don't want unification. North and South Yemen were separate countries for decades. When unification first happened there was optimism but South Yemen (which is about 20% of the total population of Yemen) was always hesitant about how little political power they'd have. North Yemen is 80% of the population and, today, almost entirely controlled by the Houthis.

I don't think native Yemeni are motivated enough to fight for unification. That's why all the fighters are mercenaries hired by the UAE or Yemen

We've seen Sunni majorities in Syria and Lebanon run for generations by oppressive Shia-supremacist regimes, so while I agree that the resistance against Ansar Allah doesn't have a lot of local legitimacy, I think you have to be a little careful about reading legitimacy into the dominant power in Yemen; once a group gets the upper hand, it can be hard to shake them off. There's a whole interesting history to how Yemen got here.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com