Comment by dktp | Hacker News Reader

Comment by dktp | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

From the outside looking in, I don't think Meta has a clear vision. I think it's a stretch to say that this one announcement makes it clear. There are AI announcements from Meta every month, recent ones more focused on coding (Muse Spark/Muse Code)

Their ads team wants AI to improve their targeting and ad creation. Some want to have frontier AI including coding. Others might want personal AI agent. Then there's the flirting with renting their compute

And I'm not even taking shots at them. I think Google is exactly the same. I think OpenAI is largely the same (though lately more following Anthropic footsteps and focusing on productivity). And I think the whole field is so new and allows change in so many places - that it's sort of normal or fine to throw things at the wall and see what sticks.

But nothing as of now says to me that Meta has a clear strategy around llms

What’s Meta’s moat? Content and doom scrolling…

I would say they should put ALL their focus on Next Generation content generation… I honestly think in the ~10 years we’re going to see cinema completely flip from high budget blockbusters to way cheaper, personalised “Choose Your Own Adventure” content but where the story changes/rewrites itself in realtime based on constant user feedback (thumbs up from popups mid movie, facial expressions etc).

Meta could be the next generation’s Disney, Warner Brothers, Universal etc

I read this take on hacker news all the time, but what indication do you have that this would be popular ?

All the streaming giants had ample budget and engineering talent to make interactive fiction happen, but didn’t, presumably because they know a) not everybody is creative that way and b) a big part of culture is that you can discuss it with others, which doesn’t work for personalised works.

If you have your kids you’ll know that the shared culture we used to have is no more. Kids these days don’t turn on the tv when they get home from school but instead go on their highly personalised feeds… so for any shared culture, we’re now back to memes (in the original sense of the word, not internet memes).

You can’t look at the big giants with their budgets and think “If they can’t do it, nobody will”. The bigger you are, the slower you’ll move. This is exactly why FAANGS buy innovation rather than build it all themselves.

I’m 100% positive we’ll see exactly what I described in the coming years and it will be from an unknown startup with two founders, no budget, and just a coffee machine to keep them going

Reply on news.ycombinator.com