IMO Audacity has never been particularly native-feeling, and I don't buy the McDonalds analogy - this release is still lightweight. It'd be a fair comment if they'd e.g. move to Electron, but Qt 6 is hardly that.
Your perspective is also valid, in that it could be phrased a little kinder. =3
Audacity was fooling no one that it was a native MacOS app, or even a particularly well designed GTK app. The fundamental idea of WX is not sound. Turns out MFC is not a great abstraction for AppKit.
Even Qt uses some higher level native UI interfaces on its respective implementations.
The only toolkit to do what it does? Qt does what it does, even if the approach is not the same (arguably superior), there’s also Tk. There’s also libui and IUP.
This is nonsensical. What are you even trying to say here? MFC isn't available on macOS or GTK.
> Just look at Unicode. It’s an unholy mess.
This seems utterly unrelated to the issue under discussion.
> Qt does what it does, even if the approach is not the same (arguably superior), there’s also Tk. There’s also libui and IUP.
None of those allow a single codebase to compile on Windows, Mac, and Linux, and get native UI elements on each.
On windows 11, Qt is usually fine if the license is still compatible... The old wxWidgets supports native OS interface targeting being truly cross-platform.
Like all eye-candy interfaces at Microsoft, it will work until it doesn't. =3
Discord is the right platform to get feedback from normies.
gimp had the same issue and i wouldnt be surprised if you also miss the old GTK UI?
making audacity feel like a modern app instead of a dusty relic isnt making it into McDonalds..
I for one applaud this upgrade -- its the polish it should have had years ago
God forbid someone actually improves a software!
But it used wxWidgets, so by definition, NOT native interface