Hacker News Reader

> I’m not packaging this application up. If you want it, just screenshot this section of the post and give it to Claude. It’ll build something useful. You see where I’m going with this.

This pretense that the entire value of source code is the "spec" / "requirement" is alarming.

The value of the code is how well-formed the spec is + how well tested it is in the real world. So prompt / mockup cannot replace code.

View on HN

Don’t forget operations and maintenance. You can have a box of vibe coded custom tools and services, but they’re all going to slowly rot as the underlying dependencies - network APIs, platform APIs, auth handshakes, reverse engineered file & DB schemas - change their behaviors and availability.

Sure, an LLM can fix it, but that assumes your original spec sufficiently described the user requirements and wasn’t just a transcript of the original session trying to figure out how how to interface with all those dependencies in the first place.

I did see where they were going and that was when I closed the tab.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com