Hacker News Reader

I have been using this for several days and have received quite a few useful reviews. The main thing that bothers me is the emphasis on a single screenshot. I always open each site into a new window to test the responsive design and browse the site a bit.

View on HN

Do you think there's a way to strike a better balance?

I wouldn't want it to turn into usability testing because it would sort of defeat the purpose (i.e. quick reviews, get first impressions, improve, repeat).

Maybe you can leave that up to the site owner. You can give us a few options pertaining to what we'd like reviewed, ie: first impression, clarity of copy, design, concept. Then list these on the review page so the reviewer knows what to pay attention to.

Thank you for the suggestion! It sounds great! I'll definitely think about how this could be done without making the process too complicated.

Could you show multiple screenshots? EG if I want a mobile and tablet screenshot to show the reviewers of my site.

Right now I have no support for mobile screenshots but this is definitely a great idea!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com