Comment by matherial | Hacker News Reader

Comment by matherial | Hacker News Reader

What an odd website. It explains everything in incredibly childish terms ("The display you’re reading this on is an absurd grid of exactly [wrong number] tiny, multicoloured light bulbs, known as pixels."), has lots of needless word-salad LLMisms ("Electricity made light effortless. The torch in your phone made darkness optional."), and all in all, feels like a wasted concept because it doesn't really say anything that isn't patently obvious: a phone has a screen and a camera and a CPU... okay? Not exactly mind-blowing.

It doesn't really even do anything to support its thesis that it's the "most intricate machine you've ever held". I don't know, I'm holding a Thinkpad laptop right now and I'm pretty sure it's a superset of what's inside a phone.

You're absolutely right.

I guess this website isn't ready for primetime yet.

Let me rewrite it all only to still have most of the same issues it used to have, and a few extra ones too.

Fair dos on the LLMisms. I'm still working on keeping my human voice despite being able to plug any words in to get a smooth AI version.

I'd push back on the childish terms. It is firmly pitched to a general audience, but I think it stands up in both depth and breadth. If you have better examples I'd love to see them.

I'd also square up on the thinkpad. It has larger and more powerful versions of some of the components, but it's also missing a lot of phones ones: the accelerometer, gyroscope, linear resonant actuator, magnetometer, barometer, multiple cameras, probably one with OIS; all in a much smaller device. Very keen to debate, tell me about your laptop!

> I'd push back on the childish terms

Are you Claude?

Why won't you respect your audience enough to write with your own voice?

I think a phone does beat a thinkpad, but not by much.

How so? They have the same radios, the laptop has more human input devices (touchpad, trackpad, keyboard, pen), quantitively better almost everything (more RAM, much better CPU / GPU, much higher pixel count, faster and higher-capacity SSD, better audio, etc)... laptop cameras are the only thing that's obviously worse.

The density of components on a phone logic board is significantly higher, which is how I define intricacy.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com