> Either comply with the law and utter an age, or you're breaking the law if you communicate online without such an utterance.
Not you. The OS distributor breaks the law if they don't give you this ability.
> And contrary to your claim, COPPA does not legally require service providers to ask every user how old they are, nor are users obligated to reply
It requires service providers to ask if you are under 13 if they collect any personal information, including email address. Users are required to respond in the negative in order to use these services without them getting permission from an adult.
> I don't think COPPA is a good example of a law working as intended.
The question is whether it is a First Amendment violation. In the almost three decades since it was proposed, it hasn't been challenged. No serious person thinks AB 1043 is a First Amendment violation either.