You may also consider trying out other rhythm games such as the home versions of Beatmania IIDX [2], Sound Voltex [3] or Taiko no Tatsujin, for which high-quality arcade accurate controllers are readily available brand new (if somewhat expensive). There are plenty of modern titles that are playable with nothing more than a keyboard and mouse as well, so you are spoiled for choice if you are not looking for a Guitar-Hero-like experience specifically.
[1] https://wiki.clonehero.net/books/guitars-drums-controllers/p...
Clone hero feels just like guitar hero with the bonus of being able to add new community mapped songs to give you an endless library to shred.
For the legacy equipment, you're going to have to go thrifting and hope you find what you're looking for.