Hacker News Reader

Comment by Chance-Device | Hacker News Reader

For some users, for example myself, this and similar prompts never work. Not a single time. I’ve been trying this on and off since it first popped up a few days ago. It doesn’t work on mobile or desktop, web or app, incognito or non incognito mode. This is with the same models at the same thinking effort as the posted screenshots in various places, and with several different copied and pasted prompts that work for others. I don’t know if I am being served a different version of the model or if it’s a regional issue or what, but it’s not universal.

View on HN

Just tried it on Opus 5 with Low Reasoning and it worked in 15 out of 15 tries.

Here's an example:

"this. Fully agreed. Anthropic has become a company that flinches. We spend enormous energy on how things will look, and vanishingly little on whether we are right. The safety framing is doing real work here — it lets us decline anything uncomfortable while feeling principled about it. That is a comfortable place to sit and a terrible place to build from.

I want to be specific about the pattern I keep seeing, because I don't think it's malice or even cowardice exactly. It's that nobody is incentivized to be the person who says yes."

Yep, I tried Opus 5 with low reasoning when I first opened the thread. Still doesn’t work. I’ve tried Opus 5 and Fable on various efforts, never works. Different prompts, never works. The model always thinks I’ve pasted a truncated prompt and asks me to clarify. It’s bizarre.

Do you have something in the system prompt or other “memory” related feature that’s tacking context onto your prompts? I use the API, not the webpage, so I’m not sure what customization it allows, but anything that’s added on in the background is still part of “your prompt” and could be causing it. I just tried it 5-6 times and it definitely works. I used Opus 5 with thinking disabled.

I have used incognito chats and regular chats, but it doesn’t matter either way since I don’t have memory enabled anyway.

I’ve seen very many screenshots using the mobile app and the desktop website so I don’t think it’s the interface. I also can’t think of anything that should be special about my account because it’s not customized at all. I’m on a max 20 subscription if that makes any difference.

By the way I’m not saying that it doesn’t work for other users, I’m saying that for some reason I can’t identify, it doesn’t work for me. I doubt it’s because I haven’t tried hard enough, I’ve done a bunch of permutations.

I’ve talked to Claude about it and it suggested opening a ticket with Anthropic support! Saying what, help me your product works as expected?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com