Why Do Autistic People Talk Like Animé Villains?

dispatchesfromtheautismwars.substack.com

10 points·barry-cotter··5 comments

So I get that the author has a lot of careful "this is my lived experience" and "this is a guess" disclaimers... but isn't it premature to ask "why", when there's nothing to back up the existence or characteristics of the phenomenon?

> when there's nothing to back up the existence of the phenomenon?

What do you mean?

I'll clarify, by "nothing" I mean no objective data, as contrasted to the author's subjective impressions I brought up just before.

There are several places where the author has created mockups of how they think some data would look if it were collected.

1000s of data points are evidence, even if they aren’t logged in a lab notebook. No one except ideologues needs a study to say men are stronger than women; the broad outline of the autistic manner of speaking is equally obvious. The details are worth study, but you have to have no exposure to the relevant populations to argue with the existence of the difference.

> The details are worth study

Oh, you mean like, I dunno, actually measuring them!?

You seem to have misheard "this is excessive extrapolation and theorized details from too little hard data" as "the most-general version of the phenomenon doesn't exist."

> 1000s of data points are evidence

Except they're the same kind my neighbor uses when he says that kids these days are different and don't respect their elders like they used-to.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com