Hacker News Reader

This presentation wasn’t too bad in terms of us vs theming, but in general throughout the lifetime of the project there’s been a strong us vs them rhetoric. I think it’s working as a marketing tactic to some extent but there are better, albeit harder ways to market the thing.

View on HN

Rust generally invites us vs them everywhere because it's just so ambitious and attractive (to some). Fil-C probably receives questions all the time about why they don't just do X or Y that Rust does. Maybe they end up supporting their position against that type of pressure and it looks like they're opposing Rust when all they're doing is justifying themselves.

Because by making Cyclone's ideas mainstream, which AT&T started alongside Cornell University, the C and C++ devs that so far felt safe from all those RC/GC languages, now had an actually problem as companies started paying attention and embracing the language's ideas, even extending the type system of existing RC/GC languages.

Thus anyone that identifies themselves with the programming language they work with, gets dragged into a us vs them discussion.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com