Hacker News Reader

Similar experience here. What's the difference between comments and reviews for that matter? There's an add comment button and an add review button, apparently tied to the same field.

Also got some after-the-fact request to sign up before getting the review of my site I was promised... not too interested in that.

View on HN

A review can have multiple comments, and should have at least one. So the workflow is as follows:

1. Enter comment. Submit it. 2. Repeat step 1. 3. Submit review.

Took me a few seconds as well to figure that out.

Yeah, the 'Add comment' link is pretty confusing. I'd consider moving the '1 comment' text below the comment box, and display the truncated comment text instead. It felt very much like the comment I'd entered had just disappeared with the current implementation.

Yeah, "Add comment" etc. is on its way out. Thank you all for your feedback.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com