Hacker News Reader

I believe you are projecting your personal misgivings onto the argument actually being made. May be better to write your own rebuttal instead?

I'm pretty sure they just did...

A rebuttal would spend some time trying to make a case, this is a petulant complaint.

One person's petulant complaint is another person's rebuttal.

I think what you're really saying is you don't agree with OP's perspective...