Hacker News Reader

Comment by zihotki | Hacker News Reader

That's a good question indeed. Also I wonder why they picked java as the implementation language.

Likely because they are a Java shop. All the IDEs they develop use Java, so they have quite an expertise in low level optimization for this language.

They also have C# expertise, but yes, Java is probably the language they have the most expertise in.

That's true, although, if you look at them, you wouldn't notice. The only mention of JVM you can see in the IDEs is in the About dialog, and the IDEs install and run their own OpenJDK, so no JVM has to be installed globally. Almost as if they were a bit self-conscious about using such an "unsexy" architecture...

Bundling a JDK with the app is the officially sanctioned way to ship Java apps since Java 9, so for over a decade now.

The JDK is too big for every app to do that, imo.

Which is why there are linking and packaging tools for trimming fat that isn't needed, or even AOT compile the application.

You mean a JRE, because the whole JDK contains a bunch of things you're never going to need.

Mind you, a default JRE redistribution makes your app at least 100+MB. Using jdeps to strip out unneeded things is a good idea if you want it to get down to 25 ish MBs.

JREs haven't been a thing in like a decade I thought.

Yeah, saying JRE is a bit of a shortcut since you're supposed to jlink & jpackage & jdance &jpray to get a slimmed down JVM released with your app, but it's closer to what would be a JRE than a full JDK

Date of commits shows this project is 3 years old.

It’s JetBrains who were synonymous with Java so not a surprise, if was a recent project would have been Kotlin (which this company created)

Probably worth saying it's a fork of orientdb from like 2010.

Because Youtrack itself is written in java

Reply on news.ycombinator.com