"This isn't objective." Correct, and we are not pretending it is. We are not handing down a scientific verdict.
Look at the top comment on their previous HN submission: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48839886
Really, the deeper problem is the upvotes that cause such posts to rise to the top of a thread and stick there, drowning out curious conversation and giving people a bad impression of the entire community. Unfortunately, the upvote problem seems basically unsolvable - people don't do it consciously and it's very much a tragedy-of-the-commons problem. So we're stuck with moderation on the comments.
Given that type of reaction is inevitable, it just saves the conversation.
also the article itself is clearly LLM generated though