And yet we can restore and preserve those books today, and experts can still read them. And occasionally, even a language that was lost completely is recovered - or a scroll that was burned in the eruption of Vesuvius: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/scientists-have-de...
Tear a page off a book and the rest remains readable. Spill coffee on a book and you can still see the letters through the stain.
In the meanwhile make a single scratch and you can't read your CD anymore. I'm sure there are forensic technologies that restores the content of the disc but if you are just a random nobody your disc is as good as nothing.
Not to mention CD drives fail, too.
You may interpret the OP as being against physical media. But I think what he is actually after is the idea that if you have a piece of physical media, it lasts forever which is false.
Books it’s very obvious when it’s deteriorating or molding, hard drives and such are not to a laymen.
I have audio CDs from 1990 that play just fine and look to be in tip-top condition. Not so much CDs I have burned in the 2000s, they seem to fade, clearly a different manufacturing process. However, based on my older audio CDs, it seems that, if manufacturers want to produce quality, they certainly can.
You can lose a lot of bits in analog audio and not notice a thing, especially as your hearing also degrades with age.