I don't see the inconsistent lighting directions folks are talking about. I'm curious what directions you guys are seeing. (FWIW - I'm a photographer). I read the lighting direction as potentially about 4pm from the photographer and rather lowish (some shade over subjects), McAfee's face shaded by the other subject, and some of the other differences (highlight on top of VICE guy's shoulder versus McAfee's for instance) very explainable by the dappled light from trees above them and in the background. Maybe I'm missing something though, I definitely haven't spent much time attempting to identify fake photos :)