No tablet with less battery life than a cheap laptop will be handy for anyone.
I might be getting too old to understand this but when I was an undergraduate student 14 years ago, I had an 1-hour-battery laptop and was 'really' useful. I can't see how a portable computer (even if I have to plug it to use it) would be 'especially useless' for students.
Coming from a latin-american country, the whole battery life issue sounds a lot like a "1st world problem" to me.
A peak 17W vs 10W draw is a pretty big difference. And that's peak power; Haswell may be even better at idling. We might see 6 or 7 hours on the next Pro (wild guess).