Hacker News Reader

Comment by rapind | Hacker News Reader

> The movie Fight Club has been correctly compared to Calvin and Hobbes.

Bit of a tangent, but I recently watched Fight Club with my son. He was surprised he liked it because he'd gotten the impression it was a dog whistle for manosphere spazzes. I was like "exactly, Matrix is actually good too...".

View on HN

Avoiding a work of art because of identity politics is no way to live life. That is true whether it is right wing or left wing identity politics. One should just give the work an honest go, and form one's own conclusions, without worrying about whether "those people" might have enjoyed it as well.

> the impression it was a dog whistle for manosphere spazzes

Everyone thinks this until they see the movie or read the book.

I mean...they _are_. That doesn't mean that they doesn't have quality beyond what those dregs see.

A lot of them praised The Boys right up to the point they realised it was making fun of them. They took years of the TV series to get it.

I remember when Fight Club came out and joke was along the lines of ”you mean the gayest movie like, ever?!” Palahniuk, the author of the book (the film changes very little) came out himself only years later. And it is so very very very queer coded, back in the early 00’s even straight people noticed it. And Matrix trilogy is of course made by two transwomen.

I don’t really understood why manosphere thinks these films as some tough guy films or something. Then again, I think I do.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com