Hacker News Reader

Comment by jvanderbot | Hacker News Reader

Right - the future of LLMs is like ol' windows XP+Dell. Commercialized "things" you run locally offline, co-designed with hardware, with a known productivity suite, and large businesses building the next generation thing and suite with 18mo release cycles (ish).

View on HN

XP? I can see the argument for enterprise support but in that case the latest windows OS is going to be virtually free and I dont know if MS and Dell etc. would even support an XP machine. Might even be required for hardware. If no enterprise support wouldnt Linux make a lot more sense?

I get that if it's offline the security downside of XP doesnt matter, and I assume XP is free, but being free doesnt really seem that valuable compared to alternatives (free linux and virtually free OS if buying wholesale).

"Windows XP+Dell" should have been in quotes. It's similar to the way enterprise productivity software was developed, packaged co-designed with hardware, and sold on an 18mo upgrade cycle assumption. It's not literally windows xp.

Oh gotcha. Yeah that's an interesting idea.

I don't see it. Leasing equipment and paying per seat license fees makes a lot of accounting and cash flow sense. Maybe when it gets to the point where you can run SOTA LLMs on consumer hardware. But that seems a solid decade and probably much more away.

Even then it makes more sense to rent the bigger GPU and get your answer faster.

There's waayyyy too much money betting on that not happening, to the point I feel there'll be regulations popping up for "safety reasons" etc to ensure the big players control this.

3/4 of Microsoft's BUILD conference the past two days were about local AI, foundry local and Windows ML along with a big section in the keynote about running local workloads on their new hardware with Nvidia. Say what you want about Microsoft's reputation, but they are a "big player" and seem to be moving in the direction of local AI first.

I would love this to happen of course, just paranoid it won't.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com