Hacker News Reader

Comment by boriselec | Hacker News Reader

Why do reasoning blocks even get encrypted? Reasoning can’t contain information that is more ‘sensitive’ than assistant response. It is annoying to be not able to see reasoning tokens.

View on HN

They are encrypted to prevent others from training on the reasoning trace. But before anthropic started encrypting the reasoning traces they were signed. The signature was to prevent the user from being able to manipulate the reasoning part of the context because this reasoning part is considered "more trustworthy" by the model. So it would be bad if the user could manipulate the reasoning to convince the model to do something dangerous/against policy. Encryption keeps this property while also preventing the reasoning from being used for training.

Sure they can. I was able to figure out Gemini 2.5 Pro's "Memory" feature's hidden system prompt because the reasoning tokens references the markdown headers by name as "blah blah says I can't refer to this", while the output would never mention them.

Yeah, I get that you can jailbreak and get that info anyway. Also that this is specific to front ends like web chat and less about API usage. But as a sibling points out it's also a good way to make post training other models harder. Mostly a "win/win" for the provider.

It's to prevent you training another model to emulate the reasoning. They want it to be their moat.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com