Or did we forget software inherently is opinionated
Unfortunately, his followers don't realize that something like a batteries-included runtime is a huge commitment to build on top of, and governance you can trust matters as much, if not more, than the lines of code.
The way this has been handled is just baffling. A Rust rewrite is supposed to be a freebie for hype, and even an AI rewrite could have been interesting if approached more scientifically and transparently... but instead the opposite of that happened.
if it works, it will keep working. they just don't want to support and maintain it and solve issues.
I think you cannot make this comparison because Rust version wasn’t in fact written by the Bun team. It wasn’t even read by them.
Yt-dlp devs made a good call. If Claude is good enough to rewrite millions of lines of Bun, it is good enough to maintain Bun fork of yt-dlp. And since Bun is part of Anthropic, they can afford it too.