Comment by ammar2 | Hacker News Reader

Comment by ammar2 | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Could you elaborate on this bit on why Github's secret masking doesn't work here:

> GitHub Actions' built-in secret masker matches registered values as exact substrings. When the exception message is rendered by Symfony Console it may wrap, embed in In BaseIO.php line N: framing, or interleave with ANSI control sequences. So the masker does not redact, and the plaintext token reaches the log.

What does this log rendering look like such that the token from that code snippet becomes interleaved enough to not be a substring match?

I'm not familiar with composer/Symfony but I would expect something like:

  Line 34: Foo bar
  Line 34: <red>Foo bar</red>

From what I can tell Symfony wraps these errors in a styled error block so it messes with GitHub's masking. For example, newlines breaking up the token are apparently enough to trick the masker since it's not a substring anymore.

For your example:

Line 34: <red>ghs_fdsafdsarewqfdsa...</red>

Is probably long enough in most cases to break to a new line.

Also, those blocks get "interleaved" like this:

<red>ghs_fdsafdsarewqfdsafdsa</red>

<red>fdsardsardsafdsafs......</red>

So there are now </red>'s within the token, also breaking the substring matching.

This is kind of eye-opening for me -- I have never thought about how styled output like this could cause logging leakages.

Aah, the newlines were the thing I was missing. That makes sense then.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com