Author here. It was the first one. (Not to take away from your point - but i will die shameful if anyone thinks I "spent time prompting.")
Either way though, I love your crappy mspaint job on that image and I agree wholeheartedly with the point you were trying to make with it. I think people overall do respond more positively to crappy ms paint memes than the AI gen memes. It's worth thinking about why that is