Hacker News Reader

Filed July 2010.

I don't understand. I saw this effect on dozens of web pages over the last decade. Do patent examiners just live in a little box?

View on HN

Patent examiners just provide advice. Even if the advice is negative, you can still be granted the patent.

The validity of any patent then has to be established by a judge in court.

I understand 'innocent until proven guilty,' but 'patentable until proven otherwise' makes no damn sense.

I agree with you. But it's important to understand that 'Patent granted' has no meaning at all.

This is entirely untrue. A patent that has been granted by the USPTO is deemed valid and binding unless decided otherwise in court or by a re-evaluation by the USPTO.

By your standard, patents are never meaningful, because a higher court (or the same court) could always invalidate the patent.

"Patent pending" doesn't have legal effect ( i think it's a warning to copycat-wannabes). "Patent granted" has lots and lots of meaning.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com