Slava's Monoid Zoo

factorcode.org

74 pointsluu8 comments

> "Can you see a way to transform a string of 8 apples "" into a string of 10 apples ""?"

Am I missing something? The only rules we have are BAB -> AAA and BBB -> BB, and we start with only A, no B, so neither of those rules can be used, so the answer is no?

EDIT: Ah, looks like you cant put emoji in HN comments. Imagine there's apples in there

The relations are bi-directional. So you can change AAA -> BAB and BB -> BBB as well.

Oh, I see. That makes sense

Yeah, that was the secret sauce that left me a bit confused

I'm too scared to leave the comfy world of commutative monoids.

Is the word problem easier if the monoids are commutative? (Or even trivial? I haven't thought deeply about it.)

I haven't previously thought about this, but I think words over a commutative monoid are equivalent to a vector of non-negative integers, at which point you have vector addition systems, and I believe those are decidable, though still computationally incredibly hard: https://www.quantamagazine.org/an-easy-sounding-problem-yiel....

Thanks, that's an interesting tidbit!

(The whole thing made me think about applications to SQL query optimizers, although I'm not sure if it's practically useful for anything.)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com