Yeah, real communism has never been tried. /s
It is irrelevant if it is "real communism" or not - it remains an objective fact that all of these regimes have derived their ideology from one very specific branch. In fact, all of them make a big fuzz over exactly that, and all of them had a history of brutally persecuting supporters of other communist ideologies.
You don't need to support any of them to recognise this. I did not make an argument about the desirability of any of them at all, very intentionally.
How, exactly, is it you imagine this is a "No true Scotsman"?
What I have argued is, if anything, that there are lots of Scotsmen, and trying to reduce them all to one is meaninglessly reductive.
In other words, I've indirectly explicitly argued against No true Scotsman.
- Communist Totalitarian Thinking
- “Never been tried” quips as a retort to, um, no one even claiming that here
My emphasis. You seem intent on attacking strawmen.