Hacker News Reader

Comment by pseudony | Hacker News Reader

Definitely. And then one could start wondering if the direction might reverse.

It would take something miraculous for the direction to reverse towards Europe. People have been complaining about European tech, economy, and freedoms (as in free speech) for decades now. Things have become worse on all of these fronts.

I think the AI act is a great example here. The EU came up with regulation for an emerging technology that basically killed the chance for Europe to compete. Lots of people disagreed with this criticism when the act was debated, but it turns out the critics were right. Europe will be buying AI services from elsewhere because Europe wasn't able to compete.

This entire way of thinking in Europe would need to reverse for there to be a chance that the brain drain changes course.

On the flip side, with the US cutting funding for scientific research, and increasing persecution of minorities within the US, I know a whole bunch of qualified scientists/researchers who are either moving to or actively hunting for a position in the EU

Really not many people outside far right proponents of hate speech (and more recently MAGA shills) have been complaining about free speech in Europe. Yes, there are laws against holocaust denial for specific historical reasons. The UK also had regulations on some Irish republican organisations access to TV, but not other forms of expression. And yes most European jurisdictions accept that speech can cause harm and try to balance this against free speech. But there is really no case that nonviolent political speech is -- in practice -- discriminated against in EU and UK.

On the IT and AI services: Europe hasn't really failed to compete in innovation, as much as scale of operation. That might change if we have a security imperative to protect our own markets for these things against an increasingly hostile US.

People have been fined and their apartments searched for insulting politicians online.

The fact that other Europeans aren't complaining about this makes it worse, because it implies that the society condones this behavior.

I'm sorry, but in no sensible society should the police raid someone's home because he called the deputy chancellor (think vice president) a dumbass on Twitter ("dummkopf"). Or more recently: police started investigating a man for calling Merz (the chancellor) Pinocchio:

https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/german-police-probe-face...

>but not other forms of expression.

France - fined for calling Macron a "scumbag":

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/m-le-mag/article/2023/04/23/french...

UK - teenager sentenced for a "hate crime" for posting rap lyrics on Instagram:

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-merseyside-43816921

This applies to other European countries too.

to europe? hardly. maybe to east asia ...

https://time.com/7379376/scientist-migration-us-to-europe/

Reply on news.ycombinator.com