Hacker News Reader

Comment by j-kidd | Hacker News Reader

Come on, Homebrew doesn't even have gcc.

I am not a Mac user, but a designer using MacBook joined our team last week, and we struggled for half a day with Homebrew. The next day, we installed MacPorts instead, and with just:

$ sudo port install python27 py27-virtualenv gcc46

we were able to proceed and get the whole stack up and running. Not to mention everything from MacPorts is installed nicely under /opt/local.

MacPorts is just way ahead of Homebrew. OTOH, Portage is way ahead of MacPorts ;)

View on HN

Interesting. This has not been my experience at all.

I had to fight for days to get MacPorts to install anything properly. It gives me flashbacks to the horrors from 3-4 years ago of compiling open source software on Linux.

Homebrew has been fuzzy kittens in comparison.

I'm a relatively new Mac user and never used MacPorts. When I search brew I get these results:

$ brew search gcc

apple-gcc42 gcc

homebrew/versions/gcc45 homebrew/versions/llvm-gcc28

I'm a bit confused since I thought that these are gcc. Can someone tell me what those results mean? :S

This is the way to go:

    $ brew tap homebrew/dupes
    $ brew install gcc --enable-all-languages

To use your new gcc-4.7.2 when installing new packages just add '--use-gcc' at the end of the command.

Hahah don't be naive. Use homebrew. Macports has been broken for years.

clang is better than gcc, IMO

By what metric?

> clang is better than gcc, IMO

Maybe. Maybe not. But I don't think that's the reason homebrew doesn't have gcc. The OP is pointing out homebrew isn't extensive, and misses some commonly used utilities.

clang either does not build or defectively builds certain things on OS X, for instance Ruby 1.9.3. I had to acquire vanilla GCC for this reason the other day, and was relieved to find it in HomeBrew.

Ruby 1.9.3 working fine here and built with clang. What was defective?

Old-ass versions of Clang would build Ruby and PostgreSQL (client) binaries which would segfault upon execution. Try grabbing the latest XCode/command line tools package and you should be fine. I've been running Ruby 1.9.3 with Clang for quite a while.

brew install rbenv ruby-build; /* rc file shenanigans */; rbenv install 1.9.3-p327; rbenv global 1.9.3-p327; ruby --version

Reply on news.ycombinator.com