Hacker News Reader

I'm on sky in the UK which is marked as not safe due to no RPKI.

It's not on the list so imagine there is a fair few missing, would be neat to have a table you could filter by country, provider type (cloud/isp etc) based on real results from users.

edit: there's a show all button to expand the table

View on HN

If you're interested, Community Fibre is a yes from this website

I get the same result for A&A, but frankly I trust them more than some random site with (apparently) an axe to grind.

My hope would be that A&A have a process manually whitelisting the route that made the test fail because in fact (as of course it would be) it's actually deliberately not signed but it is really their route.

But on some level that's like assuming the reason the guy with the handgun is on your plane is that he's a sky marshal and not that some idiot let a concealed handgun through security. I mean, sure, maybe, but, maybe not.

Without asking it's just a guess and I haven't asked. Maybe I should.

And now thanks to jsty's sibling comment I don't have to ask, thanks! It does seem like they've been more than "cautious" enough at this point and should just implement RPKI.

https://www.aa.net.uk/etc/news/bgp-and-rpki/

And here we are six years on... I have a lot of respect for A&A, but I do find it hard to sympathise with that page.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com