Hacker News Reader

Comment by hacker_88 | Hacker News Reader

Copying , Draw() is called 60 times a second .

It isn't for any reasonable UI stack. For instance, the xdamage X11 extension for this was released over 20 years ago. I doubt it was the first.

At the software level yes, but it seems nobody has taken the time to do this at the hardware level as well. This is LG's stab at it.

Apple has been doing this since they started having 'always-on' displays.

So has Samsung, but we're talking mobile devices with OLED displays, which is an entirely different universe both hardware and software-wise.

What’s your metal model of what happens when a dirty region is updated and now we need to get that buffer on the display?

Xdamage isn’t a thing if you’re using a compositor for what it’s worth. It’s more expensive to try to incrementally render than to just render the entire scene (for a GPU anyway).

And regardless, the HW path still involves copying the entire frame buffer - it’s literally in the name.

Thats not true. I wrote a compositor based on xcompmgr, and there damage was widely used. It's true that it's basically pointless to do damage tracking for the final pass on gl, but damage was still useful to figure out which windows required new blurs and updated glows.

You forget that all modern UI toolkits brag about who has the highest frame rate, instead of updating only what's changed and only when it changes.

It was, but xdamage is part of the composting side of the final bitmap image generation, before that final bitmap is clocked out to the display.

The frame buffer, at least the portion of the GPU responsible for reading the frame buffer and shipping the contents out over the port to the display, the communications cable to the display screen itself, and the display screen were still reading, transmitting, and refreshing every pixel of the display at 60hz (or more).

This LG display tech. claims to be able to turn that last portion's speed down to a 1Hz rate from whatever it usually is running at.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com