Hacker News Reader

Wow. The guy who’s been thanklessly maintaining the project for 10+ years, with very little help, went way out of his way to produce a zero-reuse, ground-up reimplementation so that it could be MIT licensed... and the very-online copyleft crowd is crucifying him for it and telling him to kick rocks.

Unbelievable. This is why we can’t have nice things.

View on HN

Mark Pilgrim isn't even the original author, he just ported the C version to Python and contributed nothing to it for the last 10 years.

If you take 5 minutes to look at the code you'll see that v7 works in a completely different way, it mostly uses machine learning models instead of heuristics. Even if you compare the UTF8 or UTF16 detection code you'll see that they have absolutely nothing in common.

Its just API compatible and the API is basically 3 functions.

If he had published this under a different name nobody would have challenged it.

Nothing to help out a thankless maintainer like allowing companies to use his work wholesale while contributing nothing back! Enjoy your nice things

Reply on news.ycombinator.com