Unironically slashdot's moderating and meta-moderating is the best long-term system I've seen.
Everything else seems to eventually cause new blood to dry up.
Everything else seems to eventually cause new blood to dry up.
And about the same frequency you’d be assigned to metamoderate, basically being asked if a moderator’s “vote” was a good one or not (you didn’t have to fully agree you’d do the same, just that it wasn’t bad).
Someone who scored low in meta moderation would get less or no moderator chances.