Hacker News Reader

Comment by r-w | Hacker News Reader

> Every single chrome-fork has shut down MV2 extensions, even Brave is about to do it

Source?

Brave said they'll try to maintain limited support for MV2 for only 4 specific extensions, but recommend Brave Shields as the go-to adblocker for the future. Google is about to remove most of the MV2 code from the codebase, which will explode the complexity soon.

https://brave.com/blog/brave-shields-manifest-v3/

Brave has perverse incentives to discontinue it because of their BAT crypto business model that rewards looking at ads.

Unfortunately even the fully open source Firefox isn't immune to the pressure from the advertising industry, with all their Google funding and their purchase of anonym.

You have no idea how BAT ads work in brave, do you?

I do, but even though they're not in the webpage itself and are as such not affected by the adblocker, brave still has an interest in the advertising industry. Many if not most of their advertising clients would use regular internet ads as well.

have you consider the possibility that... it is just too much work to merge/port the code when upstream is actively breaking them?

What's the big deal? Brave's native adblocker works pretty well.

For me it's uBlock origin or bust :)

I have a lot of custom rules in it too.

Fair enough, to each their own. I don't know if it's configurable at a file level but in the Brave settings you kind of can add your own rules. And you do have a point if the inability to use custom rules in private mode is enabled. It's pretty pernicious how they disabled that.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com