My Y Combinator S12 Story | Hacker News Reader

My Y Combinator S12 Story

argumentum.posterous.com

14 pointsargumentum5 comments

I wonder - do you think the great experiment for 'no idea' applications is going to be abandoned after the upcoming class?

There is such a consensus of thought in the startup world that "ideas are useless, it's all about execution." But, I think this is flimsy thinking. Amazing execution with a shoddy idea doesn't benefit anyone. This account seems further validation of that thought.

I think a great idea has the opportunity to build consensus among founders and aid in forming a team. It seems nearly impossible to find other people to join existing ideas and be as passionate about their promise and future.

I'm mixed.. I think there are some teams that could thrive even without an idea, as long as they are committed to working with eachother when things go rough (which they will).

idea's are a dime a dozen right? with the right team/talent within that team, execution on whatever idea you choose is what's going to matter in the end to your business and to potential investors. Great idea's have still failed and i can guarantee the multiple factors that brought that on happened because of the wrong team and incorrect assessment of product market fit

I think there's a difference between a "bad" or "average" idea that everyone on the team agrees on making and literally "no idea" (which is my own personal experience).

In terms of talent, I don't think (in all humility) that there were many teams in our batch THAT much more talented (at least on paper we were very very solid). In terms of personality there were mismatches that only came out later when tested by conflict.

I think I would disagree. I think there are plenty of really bad ideas that people are pursuing in one way or another. I think there is at least some value to the idea to start with. It is, after all, the building block upon which a startup gets going.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com