Hacker News Reader

Comment by mathisfun123 | Hacker News Reader

i write C++ every day (i actually like it...) but absolutely no one is going to switch from C to C++ just for dtors.

No, RAII is one of the primary improvements of C++ over C, and one of the most ubiquitous features that is allowed in "light" subsets of C++.

> but absolutely no one is going to switch from C to C++ just for dtors

The decision would be easier if the C subset in C++ would be compatible with modern C standards instead of being a non-standard dialect of C stuck in ca. 1995.

Of course not! Those that would have, already did!

Weren't dtors the reason GCC made the switch?

I don't think so. As a contributor to GCC, I also wished it hadn't.

Why do you think so?

For two reasons: First, where C++ features are used, it make the code harder to understand rather than easier. Second, it requires newer and more complex toolchains to build GCC itself. Some people still maintain the last C version of GCC just to keep the bootstrap path open.

I'm very far from compiler development, but in my experience, while C++ is hard to read, the equivalent C code would be much more unreadable.

This is not my experience at all. In fact, my experience is where C++ is used in GCC it became harder to read. Note that GCC was written in C and then introduced C++ features later so this is not hypothetical.

In general, I think clean C code is easier to read than C++ due to much less complexity and not having language features that make it more difficult to understand by hiding crucial information from the reader (overloading, references, templates, auto, ..).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com