Apparently Seth Godin already received more than 40 applications to make his app for free. Let's make them collaborate instead of compete...
It is easier to collaborate on code than design, which is most important as I am sure the code would be trivial, or at least not useful to reuse. 40 designers would seem like a huge mess to me, and 40 programmers would seem a bit overkill.
If I were him I would choose the best of the 40 and pay them a fair rate.